Jump to content
HybridZ

Looking to buy a welder


Perfect240z

Recommended Posts

So Im looking to buying my first welder, I just stated looking and Yes Ive never welded before. Now Im pretty sure I want to go Tig because of the versatility even though it will be a lot more difficult to handle. Anyone with experience in welding can you point me to the right direction of a affordable welder? I want it to be AC/DC for Steel and Aluminum, HF start, and 200amps Is Max i'll need. Any advice will be much appreciated.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am in a similar position. I ended up saving up for a while (!) and getting this: http://www.lincolnelectric.com/en-us/Equipment/Pages/product.aspx?product=K2535-2 though I paid closer to USD2200. I am at the moment watching lots of Tig videos in preparation for a course I enrolled in, as I haven't done anything beyond some basic stick welding years ago. I think if you know you're going to be using the welder for a long time to come, to get a decent one. If you just need to do one job then will never use it again.. then maybe a more consumable one is better suited?

 

Dave

Edited by thehelix112
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well I would be using it for body work, suspension, and possibly in the future for something else, thats why Im looking for one relatively affordable. I know after I get the body done I won't be doing anything else with it for awhile till i learn about my suspension.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Its a lot harder to learn TIG doing bodywork. Unless you're planning on welding AL then a MIG will get you through most anything you need on a car with a 110v machine. The Millarmatic 211 Auto-Set and the Lincoln PowerMIG 180 Dual Power can run as 110 or 230v machines. Both will accept a spool gun for AL welding. Make sure you start with a gas bottle, skip the flux core wire.

 

HTP is also a good choice. I've been using their MIG 2400 for 8 years now and its only had a couple minor problems that HTP phone support walked me through fixing in about 10 minutes. Their machines are made in Italy. http://www.usaweld.com/ The MIG 160DV is comparable to the Miller and Lincoln I list about. HTP machines don't have all the bells and whistles of Lincoln or Miller but they work and the company provides great support.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I started with a MIG and agree... there is little car stuff that ever necessitates a TIG and it's a whole different world. Save some cash and start with MIG first with a bottle and once you've got that handled and have a few projects under your belt, invest in a TIG. I still don't have a TIG and don't see the need to get one at least while I'm working on cars and don't see any Aluminum fun on the horizon.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well I was going to do the suspension which I thought was aluminum, and figured i would need the TIG, I knew looking into welding that im going to have to watch some videos and teach myself. I have no problems trying to get into a welding class at the JC near me, its the timing that may not work to get there. I also have been hearing about how TIG welds are more structural and have harder welds from what I heard and read. Since cash is always an issue for just about anyone I may just go with a mig. Can a mig do aluminum stuff as well? And if so is it also going to run in the over 1k price range?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Its a lot harder to learn TIG doing bodywork. Unless you're planning on welding AL then a MIG will get you through most anything you need on a car with a 110v machine. The Millarmatic 211 Auto-Set and the Lincoln PowerMIG 180 Dual Power can run as 110 or 230v machines. Both will accept a spool gun for AL welding. Make sure you start with a gas bottle, skip the flux core wire.

 

HTP is also a good choice. I've been using their MIG 2400 for 8 years now and its only had a couple minor problems that HTP phone support walked me through fixing in about 10 minutes. Their machines are made in Italy. http://www.usaweld.com/ The MIG 160DV is comparable to the Miller and Lincoln I list about. HTP machines don't have all the bells and whistles of Lincoln or Miller but they work and the company provides great support.

 

 

Just read this again and saw that you can get a spool gun for aluminum. I think Im going to look at Migs then, there's a place near me that sells welders Everlast is the name ( http://www.everlastgenerators.com/welding-equipments.php ) I think they are having a sale right now too. I would get the tank for sure, I heard Airgas lets you borrow a tank though, I don't know about how long and how much though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Its a lot harder to learn TIG doing bodywork. Unless you're planning on welding AL then a MIG will get you through most anything you need on a car with a 110v machine. The Millarmatic 211 Auto-Set and the Lincoln PowerMIG 180 Dual Power can run as 110 or 230v machines. Both will accept a spool gun for AL welding. Make sure you start with a gas bottle, skip the flux core wire.

 

HTP is also a good choice. I've been using their MIG 2400 for 8 years now and its only had a couple minor problems that HTP phone support walked me through fixing in about 10 minutes. Their machines are made in Italy. http://www.usaweld.com/ The MIG 160DV is comparable to the Miller and Lincoln I list about. HTP machines don't have all the bells and whistles of Lincoln or Miller but they work and the company provides great support.

 

I found a used HTP 140 MIG from HTP and its 489 bucks. What do you think about purchasing a used welder? Its 1000 bucks brand new, and the seller says it works. Your thoughts?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you have never welded before then MIG is probably the easiest for you to learn most body shops use MIG cause its easier and faster. As far as which one is stronger many think TIG is the strongest, but when you buy filler material they will usually be rated in 60k or more tensile strength for stick, mig, or tig so they all have the potential for being strong. MIG will be fine for sheet metal body work since you will be grinder it down and covering it with paint, but i would suggest going with TIG on suspension.

 

Car chassis and rollbars are welded using tig, the finish welds look better and cleaner, with a mig you will need to clean it up with a wire brush usually.

 

I personally prefer a TIG, and i actually had a better look weld the first time i did TIG than the first time i MIG'd.

 

Also if you watch videos comparing TIG and MIG you will notice discoloration in the base metal, the MIG always has more discoloration because of the higher amount of heat the base metal is subjected to, welders call this the HAZ (heat affected zone) and for large thick pieces of steel its not really an issue since there is so much material to dissipate the heat but with thinner sheet metal, so for someone less experienced it is possible to warp the base metal or burn holes through it.

 

Also i would recommend you take a class before jumping into it if your unsure about it or atleast have someone teach you, welding is done with a high amperage short and it would be better to have someone watching you so you have one less thing to worry about.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you have never welded before then MIG is probably the easiest for you to learn most body shops use MIG cause its easier and faster. As far as which one is stronger many think TIG is the strongest, but when you buy filler material they will usually be rated in 60k or more tensile strength for stick, mig, or tig so they all have the potential for being strong. MIG will be fine for sheet metal body work since you will be grinder it down and covering it with paint, but i would suggest going with TIG on suspension.

 

Car chassis and rollbars are welded using tig, the finish welds look better and cleaner, with a mig you will need to clean it up with a wire brush usually.

 

I personally prefer a TIG, and i actually had a better look weld the first time i did TIG than the first time i MIG'd.

 

Also if you watch videos comparing TIG and MIG you will notice discoloration in the base metal, the MIG always has more discoloration because of the higher amount of heat the base metal is subjected to, welders call this the HAZ (heat affected zone) and for large thick pieces of steel its not really an issue since there is so much material to dissipate the heat but with thinner sheet metal, so for someone less experienced it is possible to warp the base metal or burn holes through it.

 

Also i would recommend you take a class before jumping into it if your unsure about it or atleast have someone teach you, welding is done with a high amperage short and it would be better to have someone watching you so you have one less thing to worry about.

 

My friend who's almost done with his mechanical engineering degree is going to teach me. But Im also not going to try and weld something on the car till I get the hang of it. I'll practice and some sheet metal first and most likely have my friend with me. What I'll most likely do is get a mig and then when I'm done I'll practice on some other stuff, when it comes time for suspension I'll either find a tig and just break down and buy it, or I have found tig rentals.

 

I think I'm going to end up getting the Lincoln 140hd Pack since it comes with a bunch of stuff and there's a coupon at lowes right now. The only thing I'll need to get is gas and some sheet metal to practice on.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My friend who's almost done with his mechanical engineering degree is going to teach me. But Im also not going to try and weld something on the car till I get the hang of it. I'll practice and some sheet metal first and most likely have my friend with me. What I'll most likely do is get a mig and then when I'm done I'll practice on some other stuff, when it comes time for suspension I'll either find a tig and just break down and buy it, or I have found tig rentals.

 

I think I'm going to end up getting the Lincoln 140hd Pack since it comes with a bunch of stuff and there's a coupon at lowes right now. The only thing I'll need to get is gas and some sheet metal to practice on.

 

Why do you think that a mechanical engineer knows how to weld? I am a ME and the only reason I know how to weld is I was a pipefitter welder for years before I went back to school and got my degree. I have 2 welders now an Miller Maxstar for tig and stick and a Lincoln 135 with gas for Mig. I really do no need an aluminum welder.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why do you think that a mechanical engineer knows how to weld? I am a ME and the only reason I know how to weld is I was a pipefitter welder for years before I went back to school and got my degree. I have 2 welders now an Miller Maxstar for tig and stick and a Lincoln 135 with gas for Mig. I really do no need an aluminum welder.

 

Because he had to take classes on welding...lol Im pretty sure his dad taught him too since his dad did a bunch of construction type jobs. He is my go to guy since he's almost family dating my sister in law.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well I was going to do the suspension which I thought was aluminum, and figured i would need the TIG, I knew looking into welding that im going to have to watch some videos and teach myself. I have no problems trying to get into a welding class at the JC near me, its the timing that may not work to get there. I also have been hearing about how TIG welds are more structural and have harder welds from what I heard and read. Since cash is always an issue for just about anyone I may just go with a mig. Can a mig do aluminum stuff as well? And if so is it also going to run in the over 1k price range?

The S30 suspension is all steel, BTW.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you're just learning how to weld I would recommend a nice 110V Mig welder and stay away from the flux cord crap. The learning curve will be quite large if you jump right into Tig rather than learning how to Mig first.

 

If you're looking to do light to medium fabrication like floor pans, frame rails, exhaust work, or even a roll cage, a 110V Mig welder is the proper tool for the job. However, If you find yourself welding a lot of thicker material or at a high duty cycle then a 220V Mig would be more appropriate.

 

I would highly recommend taking a few welding courses. As a gear head the stuff you will learn is invaluable. If you do decide to do that get to know the instructors and they may even let you use their Tig welders for your own projects. ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...