Jump to content
HybridZ

200R4 Transmissions - Who Currently Has the BEST DEAL???


Guest Mike

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 52
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I doubt it could be done for $1200, but maybe $1500.

 

The cheapest I have gotten 4L80 cores for is about $450, you might luck upon one cheaper, but it's unlikely.

The cheapest I have bought a "good working" unit for from a wrecking yard was $1100.

So say you found a trans with some type of warranty from a wrecking yard for $1000, then $200 for the manual kit, then a few bucks more for a filter, pan gasket, front and rear seals, and then you still need a converter. A stock replacement converter is about $200, any type of mild performance converter (2000-2500 stall) is $400+, and any type of real performance converter is a $700+ deal.

 

Then you still have the issues with speedo hookup. It is a $500 kit to make it work with a mechanical speedo, or a $300 converter box, or you could use an electronic speedo for $200 or so.

 

It adds up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I doubt it could be done for $1200, but maybe $1500.

 

The cheapest I have gotten 4L80 cores for is about $450, you might luck upon one cheaper, but it's unlikely.

The cheapest I have bought a "good working" unit for from a wrecking yard was $1100.

So say you found a trans with some type of warranty from a wrecking yard for $1000, then $200 for the manual kit, then a few bucks more for a filter, pan gasket, front and rear seals, and then you still need a converter. A stock replacement converter is about $200, any type of mild performance converter (2000-2500 stall) is $400+, and any type of real performance converter is a $700+ deal.

 

Then you still have the issues with speedo hookup. It is a $500 kit to make it work with a mechanical speedo, or a $300 converter box, or you could use an electronic speedo for $200 or so.

 

It adds up.

 

Yup! What Jake said...thats one reason I went the route I did but ZGAD can tell ya that a TH400 or 4L80 is very stout unit when built right....9.34s?

 

Terry

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Okay... thats about $1700-1800 for a decent j/y 4L80E and all the peripherals not counting the speedo fixes. I'm relacing my guages anyway so the speepo issue doesn't exist.

 

Here is what I have so far...

 

200R4 BTO Stage 3 (?quality?) = $1300

200R4 Built w/ GN core (Jake) = $1900+

200R4 Raptor Stage 2 complete = $1600

4L80E j/y plus the peripherals = $1800+

 

This look right?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Jake... Yes, the price includes a stall converter. I figured about $500 for one. If I'm lucky/frugal I might be able to put a "decent" 4L80 together for $1300-1400?? Of course, this won't be the quality you can provide but it'll likely be okay in my little ride. I'm not pushing the HP/torque you guys are. Besides, a factory stock 4L80 is a fairly stout transmission. I just didn't want to go this route due to added weight and power loss.

 

Frankly... I'm STILL undecided!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The rotating mass inside a 200-4R is gonan be less than a 4L80. It has some pretty lightweight parts, but this is also the reason they aren't as strong as a 400 or 4L80.

MY personal feeling is the 200-4R can be reliably built to handle the 550-600 lb ft torque range for a "reasonable" price. They can be built to the 800 Hp/TQ range for a pretty spendy price but I think even with all the billet internals, the 200-4R will be marginal at the 800 range due to the direct clutch holding power.

 

I prefer the 4L80 in anything over the 600 lb ft range, as I can build it with nothing fancy, honestly stock, except for a 34 element sprag (same upgrade as a TH400) some minor internal mods, and a valve body kit, and they can handle 800 HP with no sweat. If I need it to go over 800 HP, I can use a better billet forward hub (same as a 400), and do some other tricks internally. I am still cheaper off than doing a billet everything 200-4R and more peace of mind.

 

I also like the programmability of an electronically controlled unit.

 

As I stated before, about 450 lb ft is all I trust even a totally upgraded 700 or 4L60E to. I know of some who have made more power with them but it almost always short lived. Sometimes very short lived.

 

The TH350, I build them and trust them to the 600 lb/ft or HP level easily. I have several proven Th350's in wheels up race cars. One ran for over 2 yrs without being touched in a mid 10 second car. It is probably still out there somewhere, the car was stolen.

I think the Th350 can probablyt marginally handle 800 HP. Chris at CKperformance states that it is hydraullically capable of 1500 HP like a TH400, but that the planetaries will only hold 800 or so. I tend to agree.

 

The 400 has been proven to handle 1200 hp fairly reliably with the right mods and honestly, it doesn't take much. I have built TH400's for a 1400-1500 HP monster truck. They were not very fancy...

 

The Glide is a good unit due to it's simplicity. No sprags to break, one 2 speed, A low band and a high clutch, man it doesn't get any easier.

 

One thiong that is good to remember when dealing with the Z car, it is a relatively lightweight package. It will make it easier on a trans.

If you were making 600 HP/TQ and planned a small stage of N2O on a 3900 lb Chevelle, I would try to talk you into a 4L80.

However the same package with a Z car, I think the 200-4R can be pretty reliable at the level of build I recommend.

I recommend this level of build because I think it is reliable, but without getting into the point of diminishing returns where you have so much money invested in a trans but for the same amount you could have already had a better unit.

Once you get into a trans, you have the converter, you have the driveshaft, you have the crossmember setup, etc. that to change units, is a real PITA.

So then it becomes cheaper to fix the unreliable unit, than to swap over to a better trans.

 

The key here is that you need to be honest with yourself and the builder of your power goals and intended use, and that way you can get a good unit up front and hopefully not have any issues.

 

In the 200-4R world, there are only a few I would trust to build me a transmission. Chris at CK is at the top of that list.

 

A 4L80E, you could likely run a wrecking yard unit reliably with minor mods. If it was healthy, nothing but a valve body kit should make it live forever in most Z car applications.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

At this point, I can feel the jello in my brain firming up. A good used low-mile 4L80 with minor mods and full manual shift is sounding pretty good. If I can find one with the ECU for an affordable price, that's even better.

 

ALL: THANK YOU for sharing your your technical savvy, practical experience, and especially your patience with an inexperienced old f-art like me.

 

Unless I hear any caveats (PLEASE SPEAK UP NOW), I've made a decision and will act on it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think the 4L80E mostly came in heavy-duty pickups with the larger motors. There were a number of changes over the years but I don't know what they were other than the flow of fluid. I chose the Quadzilla due to it's reputation and a lucky find. If this pans out, I'll probably never have to buy another transmission or have any work done to this one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...