I really have to say, I am in almost the same exact position as you are. I have done extensive research and seen all sides of the debate, and the conclusion I drew was this:
There are so many people who swear by each and every one of these setups, so it must mean that they all can do their job just as good as the next one, provided you know what you are doing.
THAT BEING SAID, there is one bit of info that might help. I was talking to the guys at Motorsport Auto, and several of them couldn't decide between the SU's or the 4 barrel, however, there was one constant theme:
the 4barrel is much simpler and easier to maintain, and the 4barrel will enhance the effects of all future upgrades to the engine.
The deciding factor was when I finally figured out that modern technology and simplicity is more important than saving a few bucks. Not to mention any speed shop can work on an Edlebrock or Holley, whereas you need a specialty shop for the SU's.