As far as I can tell from what it does when it's gone, the reaction disk seems to allow your booster to modulate the force being applied to the MC. All the booster mechanisms still move when the reaction disk is missing, the only thing that's different is that when you press down on your pedal. You'll get essentially no braking power until a point, then nearly full braking power (locked up brakes). If all of your MC's (including your original) appear to "have the same problem" in that the pedal is soft, it's a very good chance it's your RD. Is your brake system stock? No swaps of different year MC's, boosters or anything like that? The one thing that's confusing me is that your brake light comes on, I don't remember that happening when I was having my myriad of brake problems. In my 240 only 2 things turn that light on, my parking brake and that "distribution" block the MC feeds into. I believe it shuts off front or back brakes if there's a loss of pressure on one side?