I don't agree at all.
The equation for heat transfer is roughly
Q = -hA(Ts – T)
Q = heat transferred
h = transfer coefficient related to the medium
A = the area of the radiator
Ts = surface temperature of the radiator
t = the temperature of the surrounding medium.
Note that there are no time constraints or limits to the difference in temperature. The physics state that the greater the temperature difference, the greater the rate of heat transfer. The most efficient your radiator can be is when the water flow and air flow are at the maximum allowed by the system.
Since the area and the transfer coefficient are constant, the only way to adjust the efficiency is to regulate the flow of the water and air. We use a thermostat to restrict the flow of water to warm the engine, opening it as the engine heats and if it gets too cool, we close the thermostat. If the engine temperature continues to rise, we use a fan to draw cold air into the radiator. This increases the difference in temperature and cools the engine. People don't seem to have a problem understanding that more air flow means better cooling.
Maximum water flow creates the highest difference in temperature across the entire radiator. If the water flow is diminished, the cooler areas of the radiator becom less efficient.. Another effect of high flow rates is turbulence, which will cause the efficiency of the radiator to rise significantly. Tests have shown cooling rate increases of 150-500% when compared to laminar flow.
One other misconception is that you need to have cool water coming out of the radiator. The automotive cooling system is a closed system, the longer water stays in the radiator, the longer is stays in the block. The cooler it comes out of the radiator, the hotter it comes out of the block. A uniformly warm block will be less apt to experience detonation than one that has a large temperature gradient. As the coolant approaches its pressure corrected vapor point, it absorbs heat at a slower rate, pockets of steam form and the efficiency is diminished.
Stewart Components has a large amount of information on the design of cooling systems.
http://www.stewartcomponents.com/Tech_Tips.htm