Matt - I don't think the pistons are RB25, unless they were mislabeled - the box showed the correct p/n (sc7311). Of course I didnt buy directly from CP and instead used an Ebay vendor (Eric's performance parts). Nevertheless we'll take another look at how much the pistons protrude.
StrokerZedd - I'm considering the 1.8mm gasket as a fix, but we'll be taking some additional measurements today to verify if that will address the issue.
Thanks for the helpful comments guys, much appreciated.