Brian Bills (BrianV8Z), Paul Ruschman (BRAAP), and myself were hanging out in the shop today. I talked them both into participating in a ‘myth busting’ session.
We weighed one each of said motors... well the short blocks anyway. Both engines comparably outfitted.
Pictures tell a thousand words, see below....
.
.
The verdict?
The LS1 weighed a measly 4 lbs less!
Granted, there are many other considerations... heads, alternators, flywheel/clutch package, exhuast manifolds, intake manifolds, etc, etc. But, in the end, the single largest component, and arguably the largest potential contributor, shows no significant weight savings.
Obviously, this is not a scientific, lab grade test procedure we've concocted. The main goal was was to see if they were similar in weight... the answer appears to be yes.
P.S. We did weigh a pair of intake manifolds... the LS1 and the Offy pictured below. The Offy was 3lbs heavier... add another 8lbs for a carb.