Was the TDC on the compression stroke?
An easy way to tell if its the compression stroke it to get a buddy, take out the #1 plug, hold your finger over the spark plug hole, have the buddy crank the engine over untill the air in the cylinder pushes your finger off. As soon as your finger is pushed off stop cranking, that should be TDC on the compression stroke.
Then take the cap off the distributor and see what contact in the cap the rotor is pointing towards, this should be where the #1 plug wire is on the cap if its not then re-stab the distributor so it is.