Tire choice and guaranteed caliper clearance is what drove me to look at 17's. Once there, I was pretty much SOL on wheel choice. The only ones that I could find that had an offset that might work for tires sizes at 225 or larger and no fender flares are the TE37V (17x8 with 4x114.3 and 0 offset). The same wheel with 5x114.3 is +25. I don't think there's 25mm on the inside even with the coilovers.
The CCW are nice looking wheels. I love the looks of the classic. Their 3 piece are the only ones that are smallish at 17". Everything else is larger. 18 would be ok, but I think that it starts to look a bit too wagon-wheel on this car. I like the idea of being able to specify an offset. The CCWs is at $1150 (17x8) per wheel. That's a hard price to swallow. It's ~$400-$500 more than TE37V per wheel. I also looking at Jongbloed. They also have custom offsets and seem to be in the same neighborhood as the Volk.
Did you have a shop roll your fenders? On your 16x8 +13 offset setup, do you think you could have gone +25?
Since we're talking expensive customs, might as well add BC forged to this list. Still "reasonable" 🤣 at ~$3200 per set (mono-forged). Also option to buy the fifth at 1/2 price.