As always Paul, 100% dead on...
I run 15psi on a stock head gasket. All out 15:1 CR race L28 GT2 motors run stock Nissan head gaskets! The problem is detonation. If you just swap in a metal one, you will break something else (pistons, rods, crank) when you turn the boost back up.
Verify your timing tab is accurate (#1 piston at TDC, then index the pointer on the damper), then verify your timing is correct with a timing light. Next tune it for 12:1 AFR under boost, 14-15 AFR under atmospheric pressure. If the motor has flat tops, the CR is probably around 8.5:1. At 15psi I would start at an advance of 20 degrees or less.