But the plate on top is the part that connects to the car, and it only connects at the 4 bolts around the perimeter, right? Or are you saying that you didn't cut the whole center section out, just the slots. I suppose if you did that the center 4 would be holding onto two little strips of metal, but I wouldn't trust that to hold the suspension in the car.
You're right though, it definitely looks better on top.
The only camber plate I've seen for a Z that I am pretty sure is designed to go on top is the Carrera plate.