Well, the first time I used the puller, I didn't use enough heat. The all thread snapped at the nut end, toward the end of the inner threaded section, a stress riser. John said that the center section has to be heated enough for the bushings to essentially melt after I talked to him about it.
I used the puller yesterday, but I got a little mixed up on the first pin. Since I am re-using the old, shorter all-thread and have a new one, I have two lengths of pipe to work with (the pipe that slides over the all-thread). I forgot to put the coupler on the first pipe that butts against the control arm and had it sink into the bushing. That's why the first pin came out mushroomed on both ends. When I went to do the second pin I saw the pipe coupler on my other pipe. "D'oh!"
The puller worked well on the second pin and got the pin out using copious amounts of MAP gas and some tapping on the other end. I'm glad to finally put the pins to rest.